Malawi CSOs hit back at govt over patriotism stunts: ‘Senseless’

Civil Society Organisations in Malawi which led the January 13 national demonstrations over the National Aids Commission (NAC) misdirecting of HIV/AIDS funds to institutions that have nothing to do with HIV/AIDS response have hit back at government and activist Billy Banda for blaming the stripping of the commission’s principal recipient (PR) status of Global Fund grants on the CSOs’ alleged lack of patriotism, branding government’s accusations as “baseless and senseless”

Mtambo (L) and Trapence : Accusations are baselless anf senseless

Mtambo (L) and Trapence : Accusations are baselless anf senseless

Malawi government through the Minister of Information Kondwani Nankhumwa and Minister of Health Jean Kalilani recently accused Civil Society Organisations in Malawi under the Anti-NAGATE barner for reporting the diverting of NAC funding to entities that do not directly deal with HIV/AIDS intervention solely based on political manipulation or abuse in NAC’s HIV/AIDS grant decision making processes to Global Fund describing them as lacking patriotism.

Kalilani said “w hy should right-thinking Malawians be at the forefront asking Global Fund to suspend its support for us. Let us be positive. Let us be patriotic.”

Government’s accusations were earlier this week echoed by Malawi Watch executive director Billy Banda, who following his appointment by President Peter Mutharika as chairperson of Malawi Gaming Board (MGB) and National Lotteries Board (NLB), has remained a staunch ruling DPP activist and one of government’s sponsored agents that steadfastly worked hard to frustrate the 13th January 2015 anti-NAgate demonstrations.

However, in a joint statement issued by Centre for Human Rights and Rehabilitation (CHRR), Malawi Health Equity Network (MHEN), Centre for Development of People (Cedep), Malawi Network of Religious Leaders Living with HIV/AIDS (MANERELA) and Malawi Network of People Living with HIV AIDS (MANET+) the anti-NACgate CSOs describe their critics remarks as “utterly fallacious”.

“According to the concerned officials, patriotism means dealing with the matters domestically, rather than reporting them to the international community. What a misplacement of reason,” reads the statement signed by Safari Mbewe, Martha Kwataine, Macdonald Sembereka, Gift Trapence and Timothy Mtambo.

But when queried if indeed they reported NAC developments to the Global Fund prompting the fund to remove it from the PR status, Mtambo told The Nation that the world is a global village and the Global Fund or United Nations agencies have representatives in the country who could have reported the issues to head offices.

To that end, the CSOs, reads the statement, have distanced themselves from claims that they influenced the Global Fund to suspend funding to Malawi through NAC, saying the fund has all the capacity to make independent decisions on the status of NAC.

“We would like to underscore the cardinal fact that one of the core mandates of a civil society worth its salt in the country is to provide oversight and, if need be, offer recommendations to government executions for the benefit of the citizens. And this does not have to be at the mercy of an ‘invisible hand’ as Malawi Watch would want Malawians to believe,” reads the statement.

The rights groups add that NACgate was one such a scenario that seriously challenged the over-sight role of civil society in Malawi, cognizant of the devastating impact cash-gate had already done to the country.

“Having discovered that NAC had un-procedurally granted funding to Beam Trust and Mhlakho wa Lomwe— institutions that are nowhere near strategically placed in the National HIV and AIDs Response—we the CSOs found it imperative to ask government to take tough measures against the resource-abuse at NAC. Refund by the Beam Trust and Mhlako wa Lomwe, overhauling of NAC Board to necessitate its independence and professionalism were some of the recommendations we offered to government. We even offered room for dialogue on the matter. But what did we get in return? Executive arrogance peppered with government propaganda aimed at demonising the CSOs under the anti Nac-gate banner” reads the statement

The CSOs said they could not be part of the docile citizenry that tacitly supported NAC-gate in the name of “patriotism.

“We will never sacrifice the social accountability movement at the altar of a professed patriotism. We will never be part of those hand clappers who entertain evil under the guise of patriotism. Malawians of good will are the best judges of who a true patriot is in the NACgate saga,” reads the statement

Recently, one of Malawi’ leading print media Malawi News also queried Malawi government’s recent accusations of anti-NACGATE CSOs as lacking patriotism, arguing that before blaming others as being unpatriotic, government should examine the actions of those who dined and wined on the account of Aids/HIV money and consider whether they are true patriots or not.

At least 22 Civil Society Organisations staged nationwide demonstrations on 13th January 2015 in protest over diverting of NAC funding to entities that do not directly deal with HIV/AIDS intervention solely based on political manipulation or abuse in NAC’s HIV/AIDS grant decision making processes and deteriorating state of governance, rule of law and human rights.

Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

Please share this Article if you like Email This Post Email This Post

More From the World

30 thoughts on “Malawi CSOs hit back at govt over patriotism stunts: ‘Senseless’”

  1. moses says:

    politicians!!! the greatest enemies of Malawi’s attempt to develop. these crooks will always find a way of syphoning money. idiots everywhere

  2. sabiti says:

    Who is patriotic the dinners or the reporters,this money was meant to alleviate the suffering of those living HIV positive, the writting is clear on the wall the there was a political influence

  3. Malindima says:

    Why didn’t these idiots report when JB also stole from NAC? Double standard!

  4. onjoya says:

    ma cso okuba inu

  5. James says:

    A Global Fund Ndi Ndalama Zao If Someone Misuse They Have Right To Knolw

  6. Kambolo Pitala says:

    Iwe Jean Kachindani mmalo moti udzudzule pulezidenti wako mathanyula yemwe akuba ndarama za hiv, ukulimbana ndi wanthu womwe akufuna kuthandiza kuti Malawi likhale dziko lonyaditsa. Patriotism sitipempha ndipo sakakamiza.

    Bingu did not force us to be patriotic when the whole nation except achair wanuwo wakubawo, rallied behind him in his first term.

  7. where was jean kalilan when the street cleaning organisation (BEAM) and mlakho wa alhomwe was stealing funds from NAC.who is patriotic in malawi? including peter himself store money from NAC and distributed it to journalists at the state house.The National intelligence beaural led by Nicorous Dausi had ahand in milking funds from NAC.what these organisations did by reporting the malpractice is patriotism.they have the interests of HIV/AIDS TB & Malaria partients at heart.we are not here to watch some people live like kings and let other people die.

  8. Martin says:

    If the CSOs were not patriotic by reporting the issue to Global Fund,then drop the cash gate cases,coz those who reported cashgate were not patriotic.Tiyeni tizingobapo apa.This is an open game.

  9. Chiheniheni says:

    MALAWI WATCH! What is it? A briefcase NGO which has no office, not even registered by CONGOMA. Shit

  10. Iwe mtambo bwanji ukumusisita ntchafu trapence?

  11. A trapence mwavala wig ya green? Uhomo wavutadi pa Malawi

  12. Malindima says:

    They said it that if BEAM & Mlhakho wa a Lohmwe could not return the money, they would report through writing to the Global Fund. We all know that they reported a one sided story. Unfortunately by reporting negatively, their intention was to let the Global Fund to stop its funding to NAC. It is this intention that tantamount to unpatriotism.
    These are a bunch of bad citizens wishing their country bad and in this context wishing all HIV/AIDS patients to die! What a bunch of shameless idiots!

  13. special advisor says:

    But this story! Full of words and long sentences! This consition is called verbosity. I wonder if schools still teach punctuation and sentence construction? Even program ya pabwalo was more systematic and succinct in its predentation compared to this level of wishy washy writing. Rafaelo! Mentor, groom these fellas!

  14. Boyd Kilembey says:

    Saw this coming after I reported NACgate to the Global Fund. Why is Govt not blaming me too for reporting that NAC wasted money on Mulhako and BEAM, and NIB. Malawi indeed is a failed nation. We have the wrong definition of politics.

    1. Malindima says:

      You are one of them too!

  15. Here we go again says:

    patriotism means not reporting evil deeds of evil people in your country. What a shame to this failed government of DPP and its damb leader. To cover someone who hav done something bad is not patriotic and it is this kind of silence that hav destryed our country

  16. Bola kukhala citzen wa south sudan amaudindonu mudzi lamulilana nokhanokha. Malawi mungo mutenga ngati mumakhala ziweto zanu. Ndapota nanu.

  17. Chikopa says:

    Sizolakwika kukhala ndi ma cso koma ngati malawi sakutukuka kwaine anthu awa ndiamene akupangisa , nthawi ya Bingu makina amwe amadziwika kuti spy machine atagulidwa inali nkhani ya human rights, atabwela jb machine anavomelezedwa sikuti analioipa ayi koma amadana ndimunthu , ma cso akumalawi amakhandi chipani chomwe amakonda, nkhani inali yakuti Bingu akukakamiza amalawi kuti peter akhale president, ndichifukwa chake Bingu atamwalira ma cso anali osangalala kwambili nkhope zawo zinali zowawa , amati peter athana naye , takumbukilani peter akusogola ma cso mmene anapangila behave mtambo bwanji kumakana zosatila ngati iye anayima nawo, kodi munthu wakufa akanakhala kuti amazuka kumanda Bingu ndikutulukila ngati lero , sakufusani kuti zakhala bwanji kuti peter akhale president ine ndinaliko? Kulimbana ndikufuna kwa mulungu , taonani sopano mmene akuyendesela dziko ngati American smart slow but sue

    1. MBC says:

      Chikopa kumbukira kuti Makina ukunenawo anali patsogolo kukana anali Airtel ndi TNM. Airtel spent about 110 million kwacha to demonise the machine. Ngati mukuyesa bodza fufuzani bwino bwino.

  18. Chemtukanika says:

    Another characteristic of patriotism is to tell the truth only even if it is against oneself.By reporting the NACgate to the Global Fund the CSOs truely demontrated patriotism not only in Malawi but to the whole world also.The world needs to know that Malawi has some selfish and unpatriotic citizens who can misuse money meant for HIV/AIDS programs.How can the whole government accept someome to use NAC funds to buy mang’ina,ziboda, kachasu,chibuku and riders? I support the CSOs fot their stand.

  19. But is the loser here? Is it the Malawi government or ordinary citizens. Who the CSOs have helped in this whole saga???? One can argue about accountability but honest speaking if there is anywhere where Maladminstration is rampant then is in the CSOs or NGOs in Malawi. These guys they pretend as if they’re saints but if you see the way they syphon the funds you can’t believe, they’re all thieves. They join or start these organisations in order to make quick bucks

    1. MSANA WA PETURO says:

      What a stupid argument! So you mean we should not report evil? It doesn’t matter who the loser is in as long as justice is done. There are always casualties in a fight for justice. We don’t need cowards like you who close their eyes at the sight of evil or who pretend all is well even when evil is exposed infront of them. Are you a patriotic KEEN OBSERVER?

  20. bongozozo says:

    Those who chewed NAC cash are the ones not patriotic. Government shouldn’t shift the blame on CSOs. We all know how the CSOs tried to engage government. All they asked was for the funds to be refunded. Some well wishers tried to give back the embezzled money by BEAM only to be derailed by some arrogant executives kuti asatchipe. So why blaming the CSOs now? Mulakho did not even think of saying anything. Thank you CSOs for the good job you are doing.

  21. Boyka says:


  22. wanangwa says:

    Dont even apologise. These thieves have to be reported

  23. weaklicks says:

    These so called stupid CSOs raise money on behalf of Malawians and the money ends up building personal houses ,buying personal houses and sharing as allowances.They are not asked to account because both donors and them are thieves they steal from their government and the csos steal from Malawians .

  24. mwika says:

    Me and my wife have a programme on HIV and AIDS fight, can i write a letter to NAC for a family social function? I am inviting my brothers, sisters, uncles, cousins and afew local leaders

  25. Don’t bother them. For your information I also reported. It’s very easy. They have a whistle blower section. I just sent 2 links of the nyasatimes coverage of NACgate and they responded, telling me that they will investigate and keep me updated.

  26. Achimidzimidzi says:

    Kodi patriotism ikutanthauza kadya ndalama mopada dongosolo eti?

  27. Alfred Munduwabo says:

    How is looking wise now ?

Comments are closed.

More From Nyasatimes