 |
 |
 |
 |
National
Malawi failed state indeed – columnist
|
By Nyasa Times Reporter |
January 22, 2012 · 36 Comments |
One of Malawi’s leading newspaper columnists on topical issues, Raphael Tenthani, has underlined the fact that the country is indeed a failed state.
Last year John Kapito, who chairs the state funded Malawi Human Rights Commission, grabbed newspaper headlines when he described Malawi as a ‘failed state’. Kapito noted that there clear signs that “government has collapsed” and has completely abandoned management of the country as demonstrated by the economic problems being experienced.
Writing in his Muckraking on Sunday column published in one of Times Group titles, the Sunday Times, Tenthani who is also Associated Press and BBC correspondent, highlighted that the state has almost collapsed and that no one is in control.
Mutharika: Failed laeder
“If you think I am lying about no one being in control, did you hear about the whole police service tear-gassing primary school kids in Lilongwe whose only crimes were simply protesting against lack of classroom space and teachers? This is their right under the Constitution,” writes Tenthani.
“If the whole police service has to teargas five- to 10-year-old kids – who were simply asking what rightly belongs to them – do you have to when 19 unarmed protestors are killed in cold blood? Do you think anybody is in control here? May be that is why we invite the whole army to control even toy-toying vendors, we ask the military to control fuel queues. My foot!”
“If that isn’t a sign of a failed state, then I don’t know what a failed state looks like,” Tenthani writes.
Mutharika worst leader
In his column, Tenthani also highlighted that President Bingu wa Mutharika “just might succeed in becoming the worst of the three presidents we have had since independence.”
He argued his point, saying: “Dr. Banda had his own issues on human rights but at least people had food security most of the times. Nowadays bumper yields are just on government files while the real Malawians are starving silently. Bakili Muluzi too veered off the script in his second term but let us give credit where credit is due; we never spent two years and counting on fuel queues.”
Tenthani said after experiencing the first two years of Mutharika’s second term “whoever dubbed Muluzi’s era as a ‘lost decade’ are surely busy revising their views.”
The Mutharika administration has become under fire since forex and fuel shortages hit the poor nation a year, leading to hikes in prices of consumables.
Tenthani says Mutharika has slightly over two years to “redeem himself” but pointed out that his tendency of blaming everyone but himself “doesn’t inspire any confidence.”
“Muluzi, John Tembo, Joyce Banda – or even Satan himself – might be easy scapegoats but at the end of the day it’s Bingu wa Mutharika who is the tenant in State House and it’s to Bingu wa Mutharika we look up for solutions.”
“We don’t want our president to be heckled by jerry can protestors; neither do we need street vendor or street urchins to insult the modesty of our wives, daughters, mothers, sisters, cousins and aunts. But if he continues to snooze on the job, people will continue to wave yellow jerry cans at Bingu and spread rumours that the Big Kahuna paid people to harass women to deflect people’s attention from the current woes,” writes Tenthani.
|
|
Tags: Bingu wa Mutharika, economy, governance, human rights, John Kapito, Raphael Tenthani
36 Responses to “Malawi failed state indeed – columnist”
Leave a Reply
- Girl-child education key to safe motherhood -JB
- Soccer – a growing death trap?
- Positive mindset: African’s way to prosperity
- Lipenga at it again: Bingu was too hasty on ‘Nsanje Slab’
- MRA continues sexing up figures
- Malawi ‘bisexual’ mum fights deportation from UK
- ACB arrests fierce DPP youth governor over YEDEF loans
- Scrap off retrogressive taxes, IBAM says
- Peter Mutharika shunned at Cup presentation
- Paladin, Malawi workers agree to end Kayelekera mine strike
N/A
Polls
Loading ...
Journalists like Raphael always blow things out of prportion out of Hatred against the President. If anything he wishes this govt bad and downfall, and has apersonal score to settle with Bingu,
there has never been a good article from him praising this govt. Bingu has mismanaged the country in one way or another but Malawi is not a failed state, its a state that is sailing in trobled waters because of bad decisions and poor polcies. Please if you wish Malawi to fail you will alson fail, because the Govt is not run by one person, even what you do as a reporter can contribute to a failure of a Nation.
Like
0
ReplyHmmn. well spoken ! The trouble here is that we live to believe things will change themselves No ! way.We can talk and say so many things , but the important thing is to change .The world has changed and it will never be the same.Create a task team from all walks of life to start brain thinking serously on the way forward .
Like
0
ReplyLet me agree with Sparks that Malawi is indeed not a failed state but obviously has bad and greedy leaders with not only bad but worst Government.
Like
0
ReplyThumbs Up Raphael This Is Really What Is Happening On The Ground.
Like
0
ReplyThe use of dire predictions or alarmist descriptions does get one’s attention, but to say Malawi is a failed state is a bridge too far. Perhaps you mean it has a bad government. A failed state has no effective central government.
I was in Malawi recently and, while I admit there is economic hardship; that the government has sadly and inexplicably embarked on bad social policies; and the President has exhibited breath-taking political ineptitude, there is a functioning framework of government and democracy. Yes, there is a strong tendency for the government to stump on people’s rights (as would be the case everywhere), but the population know what those rights are and are prepared to put their lives on the line to defend them; for me, this is a sign of a maturing democracy.
Because of a bad decision to expel the British diplomat last year (taken with a rare display of raw arrogance and political short-sightedness) aid was cut off. As a result (partly at least) the country experiences fuel shortages and other problems. But Malawi is still there: the quality of public transport has never been better, telephony is ubiquitous, public hygiene is excellent, and yes, there is public debate.
So is Malawi in the same league as Somalia? Absolutely not! There may, in fact, be a silver lining in the country’s economic woes: it might learn to live within its means.
Like
2
ReplyYay Raphael!
Like
1
Reply