The other side of the story on Kanyama’s resignation as Malawi Police IG

Paul Kanyama’s resignation as Inspector General (IG) of Police had all the theatrical elements attached to it. Even if it were not for his summoning a press briefing to announce his bowing out at a time Parliament was in the midst of debating his confirmation, Kanyama’s move was all the same going to qualify as dramatic considering that he had been on the much coveted rank in the Malawi Police Service (MPS) for only about three months.

Paul Kanyama 'pulled a fast one'

Paul Kanyama ‘pulled a fast one’

Those working in the MPS will testify that apart from being a mark of recognition bestowed on a deserving officer, any promotion — including that from the basic rank of constable to sergeant — triggers immeasurable personal prestige. A sense of pride that, at least, one is going up the lengthy police service ladder.

But Kanyama chose to step down from the highest office in MPS, citing health reasons while the media speculated that the professional cop sensed danger, nay embarrassment, coming from Parliament as most opposition legislators were bent on rejecting his confirmation to continue lording over the men and women in uniform. In police parlance this could as well be some sort of “tactical withdrawal” on the part of Kanyama.

The danger, nay the embarrassment, for not approving Kanyama’s appointment, so we have been told, was that he does not have, among other several requirements, the academic credentials befitting one to occupy the office of IG. But whether the chief cop resigned on health grounds or sensed danger and pulled a fast one (to borrow the expression used by Nyasa Times) is a story that has already been fully debated. What, rather, should belabour us now is the debate on what, really, are the requisite “academic” credentials for one to competently hold the position of IG and where can one acquire them from.

As a starting point, it is imperative to understand what the MPS exists for. The core existence for the MPS as envisioned in the institution’s vision and mission statements is all about ensuring that Malawi is safe and secure. Of course, the mission statement goes into the specifics but, in summary, they all reflect two concepts: Safety and security.

Now, you do not just wake up one day and become a police officer. Currently, the Malawi Government, under the Ministry of Home Affairs and Internal Security, has police training schools at Limbe in Blantyre, Mtakataka in Dedza and Mlangeni in Ntcheu where recruits are groomed to become professionals in “creating a safe and secure Malawi”. Then there is the Police College in Zomba where officers undergo training for higher and more challenging positions in the service.

Unlike is the case elsewhere, the police training schools in Malawi do not offer any professional certificates. And, save for some ‘valueless’ Certificate of Attendance, the Police College in Zomba might be the only college in Malawi that does not offer diplomas let alone bachelors or masters degree certificates. Something is, surely, wrong here.

Look, as far as professional police training is concerned in Malawi, for one to reach the level of being promoted to any commanding position in the service (as was the case with Kanyama before he was appointed IG), they must at some point or the other be a student at the Police College in Zomba, the highest police institution in the country. In view of this scenario, one wonders what should really be the requisite “academic” credentials for Parliament to consider when confirming an appointee to the position of IG in a country where the only highest institution for training police officers does not offer strong and valuable papers.

It is true that currently there is a horde of graduates in the police service with bachelors or masters degrees tucked under their armpits but it is also true that these are not graduates who specialised in the profession of “creating a safe and secure Malawi”. They are graduates who, unfortunately, specialised in fields that have nothing to do with police science. And most of them, sad to say, are a bunch of frustrated souls who joined MPS after failing to secure employment in their respective fields of study.

Therefore, in as far as the situation stands now, almost everyone who works for MPS, Kanyama inclusive, is “educated” and a “graduate” because they all passed through the corridors of the same police training institutions that the country boasts of. The very same institutions that ensure one remains with miserable education credentials if they have chosen to be career cops.

There have been both formal and informal suggestions that for the MPS to reform, its departments should be headed by graduates. But this still begs the question: Which graduates? Those who graduated in education, accountancy, journalism or medicine but ended up finding their way into the MPS? Really? What has a paper in these fields got to do with security and safety matters?

It is an uncontestable fact that we must value academic credentials but it is also an uncontestable reality that such academic credentials should be those befitting the field one aspires to work in. If you ask those in the know, they will tell you that one of the highly regarded IGs to have ever headed MPS is the late Mac William Lunguzi but he, too, was a graduate of the very same police training institutions we have in the country.

Actually, so it is testified, it was Lunguzi (a ‘non-graduate’) who introduced the idea of recruiting graduates from other fields into the police service. But, maybe, where he failed was to moot the project for MPS to embark on the mission of producing bonafide police graduates.

And, maybe, it is high time that the Police College which is based in the country’s old capital city graduated into a full-fledged institution offering courses at bachelors and masters degree level so that those officers appointed to the office of IG should be saved from the danger, nay the embarrassment, of being rejected by Parliament on the grounds of education credentials.

But, for the time being, let any officer who has the experience, stamina and aptitude to inspire and motivate our men and women in uniform qualify to be crowned as IG. It is not safe for the nation to be changing IGs within a period of three months.

  • The author once worked for the Malawi Police Service but has written this article in his personal capacity
Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

Please share this Article if you like Email This Post Email This Post

More From the World

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Zangazanga Ncqube
Guest

The author is right.

makito
Guest

This is retrogressive thinking. Are the graduates not subjected to the same training? Things need to change, evolve to be more precise. Anthu a std 8, form 2 ndi form four should be phasing out in the system, actually form 2 should not be a required qualification anymore.

There is no point in hating graduates, whether frustrated or not, just make the conditions good for highly educated people to choose policing as a profession. Academic qualification is just a foundation.

Anthu obwenzera kumbuyo dziko are those with such retrogressive thinking.

Lusubilo Jose
Guest

Police graduates are leftovers of these shabby univesiities like the Mzuni, khondowe, and the Advebtist @ Mlangeni in Ntcheu who eben when promoted to those senior ranks they wil stil be looking 4 a Form 4 graduate guidance! Police is Police and Chanco is Chanco. The 2 dont mix. We in Malawi Police need our own college and profuve our own graduates. In that sense we wil be selecting graduate IG who are wel trained in Police work. NOt these foest, graduates we hav in police. Ñö

mwama
Guest

This is a very good observation on the part of the author. I come to understand now that we have security lapse because we entrusted our security into wrong people, the people who joined MPS out of job frustrations. MPS IS NOT THEIR PASSIONATE JOB.

Liberal democrats
Guest

I second without ANY equivocation

General Aididi
Guest
I find it funny that the issue of somebody being a graduate in order to be confirmed as IG should be put on the floor by MPs. In the first place, the majority of the MPs are not graduates themselves and I find it hard to believe that they can attach the importance of education selectively. The Public Appointments Commitee of Parliament is Chaired by a former Fire Officer and from his group some are musicians, postal officers, business people etc. In fact one of them wrote his MSCE when he was Deputy Minister during the Bingu era. These are… Read more »
Kanyimbi
Guest

Six months training deserve a certificate of attendance. But now the National assembly should discuss the possibility of sending police officers to Mzuzu University if I am not making a mistake. It seems Mzuni offers degrees in security services.

MMALAWI
Guest

The author surely has little or no university education, nor does he know about management of institutions. It’s obvious that a graduate is better equipped for a management job than an MSCE holder. And in this age and era, you can’t have someone without a college degree heading a whole department of government, let alone a crucial security arm like the Police Service with so many people under him! One, he may not command respect from his better educated juniors and two, he would lack the skills to adapt to a continually changing operating environment.

Concerned citizen
Guest
From what has happened with IG Kanyama, it is obvious that the MPS training program has shortfalls, in that it does not appear to give potentially very capable police officers, with exceptional leadership and management capabilities, the ability to achieve their Bachelors and Masters in criminal justice or police science from the Police Training School. This needs to be looked into as the nation is appearing to miss out on some high caliber officers who were not afforded the opportunity of perusing their Bachelor and Masters. Probably the Police training school should partner with Mzuzu University, to ensure that the… Read more »
Luka Sitima
Guest

when a person is leaning at any educational institution the end out come is a valid Certificate; being Diploma, Degree etc. but its so sad that our Highest Police Collage offers only cetificate of attendance as some one is attending a seminar, they need to see what to do like joining with MANEB to help them in this issue, its not good at all, its so shameful for one to be at a collage to come out with only a certificate of attendance.

wpDiscuz

More From Nyasatimes