Those calling for federalism are actually looking for recognition

Following the fall of Berlin Wall and the Soviet Union in 1989 and 1991, respectively, American political scientist, Francis Fukuyama wrote an essay – later published as a book in 1992: The End of History and the Last Man. In it, Fukuyama argues that the evolution of human societies is not open ended; the evolution of these societies would eventually end, when humanity has achieved all its deepest and foremost longings. He described that ending as The End of History.

For Fukuyama, the fall of the Berlin Wall and the Soviet Union was the triumph of liberal democracy over communism – an end to ideological differences and therefore no need for further struggle for ideological shifts. This does not mean important and historical events would never take place again, indeed, a decade later the world witnessed the 9/11 Al-Qaeda bombing of the Pentagon and the World Trade Centre Twin Towers in the United States of America.

Federism campaigners: Some MPs from the North Malawi backing calls for power-sharing

Federism campaigners: Some MPs from the North Malawi backing calls for power-sharing

Since then terrorist groups have mushroomed all over the world, causing sleepless nights in the corridors worlds’ super powers. Two decades after Fukuyama’s theses, North Africa and Middle East witnessed political uprisings (the Arab Spring)people fighting to free themselves from decades-old dictatorships. People longing for an ideal place where personal freedoms and a sense of personal worth are no longer a preserve of the privileged few.

It is human nature to break free and fight for what one considers right and just. This is why autocracies and oppressive regimes eventually fall. Recently there have been a wave of demands by semi-autonomous states and regions for self-governing. From Spain’s Catalan region, Zanzibar, to Scotland where those seeking secession narrowly lost in a referendum, which would have seen Scottish people breaking away from United Kingdom. Today United Kingdom is working on power devolution so Scotland can have a bigger say on how Britain is governed. The vote was lost but something significant has been gained.

In Malawi there is an on going debate about federalism. The calls are in response to president’s Mutharika’s lack of inclusiveness in his cabinet and top government appointments. There is also a sense by the people of northern Malawi that their region has been neglected, development-wise, by successive Malawi governments. Malawi has had 5 presidents since its independence in 1964 – Hastings Kamuzu Banda from central region and the remaining four from southern region, Bakili Muluzi, Bingu wa Mutharika, Joyce Banda and Peter Mutharika, in that order.

Political language championed by Bakili Muluzi in Malawi has it that leaders only develop their home districts. I cannot be sure whether this is the case in reality but the notion has been challenged by recent revelations that Machinga, Muluzi’s home district, is the only district in the country without a boarding secondary school.

Yet, the sense among most Malawians remains that only regions where presidents and majority of cabinet ministers come from are bound to get significant development projects. Unless there is concrete evidence, this remains a myth.

Nonetheless, those calling for federalism (forget the secession calls for now) base their argument mainly on this. Critics and detractors have called those calling for federalism greedy, selfish and power hungry. Yet, as Fukuyama observed in The End of History, this is just human. Fukuyama recognises a quest for recognition as a key human condition, which has, in fact, has been the main driver of historical changes and evolution of human societies throughout history. People have fought wars and have died over it.

It is a condition, which according Fukuyama, the Greek philosopher, Plato, identified as thymos. This is “an innate human sense of justice.” Fukuyama’s work has drawn a lot of criticism, some justified and some for the lack of understanding but it offers some useful insight into the current debate on federalism in Malawi. I doubt that those calling for federalism genuinely believe that federalism and national development are the same thing.

Whether they know it or not, those calling for federalism are actually looking recognition. They are tired of being treated as second-class citizens, at the mercy of Other people.

No one in their right minds thought multiparty democracy would bring development to Malawi but 21 years on Afrobarometer statistics indicate that over 70 per cent of Malawians still prefer democracy than reverting to one party rule. Never mind the country’s daily whining about poor service delivery, perennial hunger, colossal state corruption and massive unemployment. Freedom and a sense of personal worth matters.

 

Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

Please share this Article if you like Email This Post Email This Post

More From the World

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Barton Chikaya
Guest

Kodi inu maNortherners, mukapasidwa dziko lanu loyima palokha, mudzakwanitsa kulemba ntchito amene adzachotsedwa ntchito ku mwera ndi chigawo cha pakati? Nanga ana anu amene ali ku mauniversity,makoleji ndi sukulu zosiyana-siyana mudzawapatsa malo ophunzilirako?

Muganize mofatsa tsiku la referendum lisanafike.

Chigumbuli
Guest

Federal system of governing in this country already exist. Ask our churches i.e. CCAP, Catholic, Seventh Day etc. Mukandifusa ineyo i will tell you that this country requires development. Development everywhere. The question should be how do we achieve that? Federal system if it is based on regionalism then it is a wrong track. Why? Because later on it will become districtism, then areasim, therafter villageism etc. However, we Malawians are very intelligent people. The problem here is development across the country. Let us find a lasting solution to the existing problem of development across the country.

Piper
Guest

You wouldn’t be talking now if it wasn’t for someone talking about multiparty democracy back in the days. Now someone is talking federal system and you are saying they only want recognition ? Think first before you open your mouth and show everyone that you are incapable of using your brain !! I rest my case …..

Mjumacharo
Guest

Inya we have never been recognised as true Malawians bu since 1912 we have shaped and contributed to the Malawi/Nyasaland history polically and economically. If no one will recognise us Northerners then we will recognise ourselves. If someone is afraid of seccesion or federalism then they must start treating northerners as true Malawians NOW!!

mr me
Guest
some of you the so called lomwe’s whether chewa’s I suggest you are sick minded and that you are talking” commenting” no sense here because your fore fathers are the creators of this so called nepotism. This thing of nepotisim started long time back only that this time mwatha mantha and that you are doing it plainly. And winawe you saying we the Northerners should go back to our homes kumathengere, watch your big mouth bady waiwala kwanu kuja you still using those round houses yet kumatukwana apa mbuzi ya munthu iwe, my last word is that what goes around… Read more »
Inu
Guest
I think it is typical for people to see other people’s weakness than their own. Do you remember Chakufwa China’s first executive committee of AFORD when it became a party? Was it not pure nepotism? In fact many people then knew who Chihana was but his tribalistic attitudes made him lose the election. So do a self reflection and you will see why people have issues with the people from the north. Again it is plain simple. How many tribes are in Malawi? There are Senas, Mang’anjas, Lomwes, Yaos, Ngonis, Chewas from the central and Southern regions of Malawi.. Why… Read more »
donie chigwambala
Guest

#INU…..then let northerners become independent coz ur just crying here as if northerners are still clinging to u assholes!!!

mai nsato
Guest

Atumbuka mukubowa zedi. kazipitani ku thengere kwanuko. wakuletsani ndaniyo????

Piper
Guest

Let them go and we stay right here in Bangalala !!!

mthakati
Guest
I had hoped this would be the perfect forum to have this discussion but I see it is wasted on some of these bozos making the stupid comments here. I will still say my piece. I agree everybody seeks recognition ( I prefer the concept of validation) from their society or others that they look up to. Look at our political history. We have glorified John Chilembwe, Kamuzu Banda etc, which is rightly so, but they did not do it alone. We rarely recognize those foot soldiers from all over the country, and Nkhatabay is particularly overrepresented. The Kanyama Chiumes,… Read more »
francis
Guest

this is what this forum is here for well said mr some of these people am nt sure why they open their big mouth.they even dont knw the meaning of distributing the cake of the nation equally it is time justice need to be served

Mbanangwa
Guest

The way to go is by ‘federal system ‘ of government. MCP backs it and if the north backs it, the referendum will carry the day. What has triggered this debate? Ignoble leadership of Bingu.

VYOTO
Guest

WHEN LATE CHAKUFWA SIMBI YAMOTO CHIHANA CALLED MCP THE PARTY OF DEATH AND DARKNESS WAY BACK IN MARCH 1992, SOME SLEEPY AND SHALLOW MINDED PEOPLE ALSO THOUGHT LIKE THE WRITER OF THIS ARTICLE THAT CHIHANA JUST WANTED COVERAGE BY BBC AND WORLD RECOGNITION.YEARS LATER CHIHANA’S CALL LED TO THE ROMAN CATHOLIC FAMOUS PASTORAL LETTER OF ” LIVING OUR FAITH” THEN REFERENDUM THEN THE MULTI PARTISM AND THE MUTHALIKA POLITICAL DYNASTY OF TODAY.BELIEVE THIS FIGHT WILL RESULT INTO SOMETHING POSITIVE AT THE END OF IT.

Inu
Guest
Yeah, politics did change, but then what has the north gained? I remember during the transition to multi-party politics, people romanticised the process just as now. Malawians want to change things without deeply thinking about how that change should serve them. We can do a lot better by changing how we value government property, how as individual citizens contribute to our country and the values that we embrace. In our current status, not much will change even if we introduce federalism. It will just be a change of actors but the same scene. For sure now, multiparty has failed to… Read more »
Bubu
Guest

Look at the bigger picture guys. Its first about North getting something than the nothing its having or has had in the past. Recognition can not be avoided here and its not a primary motive.

wpDiscuz

More From Nyasatimes