Who’ll remember Cashgate? History of modern Malawi

Malawi’s self-enriching officials need to know they will be judged not just by an imperfect judicial system, but by generation upon future generation of their compatriots.

High-level corruption has long been endemic in Malawi, but two important changes provide promising signs of this being challenged.

Cashgate suspects walk in shame covering their face

Cashgate suspects walk in shame covering their face

The first is the attitude of President Peter Mutharika towards the Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB). Unlike former president Bingu wa Mutharika, who led the country from 2004 to his death in 2012 and who was Peter’s brother, the current President Mutharika is not actively obstructing the ACB’s work.

In fact, he appointed the industrious and brave Mary Kachale to be his Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), and the DPP and ACB are reportedly working without obvious political interference from the top – though how long this will last is anybody’s guess.

The second shift happening today is that Malawi’s political culture of secrecy looks to be weakening. In his three decades in office, Malawi’s first president, Hastings Banda, put a strong emphasis on deference. The motto of his Malawi Congress Party (MCP) – now the main opposition – was “Unity, Loyalty, Obedience, and Discipline”, and one of his legacies has been a lack of transparency. However, there are suggestions that this culture is beginning to break down in the Lilongwe High Court where high-level fraudsters are starting to spill the beans under plea-bargaining arrangements.

The case those in court are speaking out about – and which the DPP and ACB have their hands full with – is the huge government scandal known as “Cashgate”. In this long-term case of high-level fraud, millions of dollars of public money were channelled into private accounts through construction companies that provided the government with bills, but no services.

The details are only beginning to emerge, but as the stakes get higher and the sense of outrage grows, Malawi’s peaceful atmosphere is becoming tainted by resentment and violence. Three years ago, Paul Mphwiyo, the former Budget Director at the Ministry of Finance and the man now named by Kachale as the Cashgate “mastermind”, survived a murder attempt. (Mphwiyo implicated former Justice Minister and prominent lawyer, Ralph Kasambara.) Furthermore, this July, the bullet-riddled body of the ACB Director of Corporate Affairs, Issa Njauju, was found in Lilongwe next to his burned out car.

Lucius Kondowe, ACB’s director, admits that his officers are “terrified”, and Cashgate witnesses are now insisting on armed guards.

A history for the future

As the full scale of Cashgate emerges, it is provoking some wider reflections in Malawi on national identity and public responsibility. This most recent scandal saw officials use their public office to enrich themselves massively, but this phenomenon is far from unique in the country as the record of its presidents shows.

Starting with Hastings Banda, an investigation found that he had accumulated at least $320 million in personal assets while in office. His successor Bakili Muluzi, who ruled from 1994 to 2004, had been a small-time businessman but also lived in great opulence as president. He faced corruption charges after stepping down, but as a Commonwealth special envoy, he is now supping with the notorious king of Swaziland and his teenage wives. His prosecution for financial wrongdoing is losing momentum, while his son, Atupele, is a cabinet minister in Peter Mutharika’s government.

The next man, Bingu wa Mutharika, a former taxi driver, commissioned a vast private palace while in the top job. Located in Thyolo and built for Bingu by a grateful Portuguese roads-contractor, the residence towers like a stranded white whale over the neighbouring houses of poor tea-estate workers. Brother Peter inherited the property.

Meanwhile, the colourful Joyce Banda, who completed a brief term from 2012 to 2014, now spends all her time in voluntary exile, feted by the international community but refusing to answer questions in Malawian courts about the disappearance of 24 billion kwacha ($43 million) during a mere six months of her presidency between April and September of 2013.

Malawi, one of the world’s poorest countries, is now being described as a kleptocracy in some circles, and international aid is drying up. The contrast between the lives of the majority of the population and elites caught with suitcases of stolen government money – not to mention those who successfully enriched themselves over years in power – are as clear to see as ever.

Malawians are now awaiting details of the latest scandal to emerge, but as they do, a deeper question is also being asked: Namely, while the country’s political leaders do not seem to fear the judicial system enough to deter them from fraud, why do they also not fear the judgement of posterity?

One possible answer to this is that Malawi’s leaders have little sense of history and their own place in it. Of course in order to tackle a culture of impunity, the country’s institutions will have to be strengthened in various ways. But at the same time, perhaps Malawian academics also need to be invited, as a matter of urgency, to write a new History of Modern Malawi – a history that will give the country’s leaders a sense of posterity to which they will one day be answerable.

A sense of the modern history of the country is lacking in Malawi, and although a new understanding of this history would not end impunity or high-level fraud, it might help create a sense of unity and highlight the fact that Malawi’s leaders are accountable to their people and their country not just now but forever more. It would remind those that might be tempted to enrich themselves to the detriment of their country that they will be judged not just by Malawi’s imperfect judicial system, but by generation upon future generation of their compatriots.

  • Nick Wright is the former Malawi correspondent for Africa Confidential and was previously a history lecturer at the University of Adelaide.
Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

Please share this Article if you like Email This Post Email This Post

More From Nyasatimes

More From the World

22 thoughts on “Who’ll remember Cashgate? History of modern Malawi”

  1. Zidura Mtengo Undigwere says:

    In the modern world, we are mostly defined by one’s profession; by how we make a living.
    Sure, the late Bingu drove a “taxi” at one point in his life: sometimes you do what you gotta do. The wtiter is being disingenuous, to the nth degree, by not even acknowledging Bingu’s economics credentials. (And HKB’s and APM’s also.) The guy (Bingu) was a Master in Economics, for crying out loud. And, from the dawn of Malawi’s independence, he made most of his living as an economist. Did he not?
    So, stop belittling Africans, for whatever reasons, Mr Nick Wright.
    Show some “ris” for a change.

  2. clement says:

    Afisi inu mwabaiba lero mukubisa nkhope asakhwi. Mwationjeza pa Malawi ndiumbava wanuwo. Anthu amenewa osawanyengelera abweze ndalama plus interest ndikukagwira ukadi. Agalu inu mxieeest

  3. nachisale says:

    Nick Wright again with the usual European `I know Africa/Malawi better` attitude and condensanding perspective. Our leaders might have failed us but Europeans or the British like you should shut up because you are the worst thieves and hypocrites. You are the people who use our leaders to steal our resources through unfair foreign investment regime and international trade – how much has Europe stolen from Africa/Malawi including fraudulent contracts and unashamed keeping of our artefacts in your museums in London. In fact, Africa Confidential is a racket that makes money out of writing and soeculating on our misery and mess which you Europeans have created over the years from slavery, colonialism to neocolonialim. Can you explain who benefits most from Malawi`s Paladin uranium mining, South Africa` Marikana mines? By the way, how much land and farms do Africans own in Europe? So, leave Malawi alone because you are the same people writing rubbish, creating a bad image of Malawi so that by the time our oil and more minerals come up, you buy them cheaply and defraud us. Of course, so that people like you can continue writing OUR distorted HISTORY. Leave us (Malawians and Africans to evolve and reform/tranform our country and continent. Africans do not concern ourselves with the filth in the domestic affairs of Europe and Britain.

  4. Cyrus Mwenenyimbiri says:

    Africa Confidential?

  5. Mzee says:

    Cashgate is not the worst my friend. As a public servant i get amused by such shallow articles. The malawi government loses more than what was lost through “cashgate”. Mind you the UK is sitting on millions of our money stolen by British Asians but UK is not interested in sending the money back to mw. The system is what is wrong. Politicians connive with public servants to defraud govt. Why do you think Llomwes get all the plush and key jobs?

  6. Matey U .Mopiiya says:

    Nick Wright ,I think you don’t have enough information and the truth about Dr HKB’ wealth ,what you have written are just speculations ,Sir David Steel ,the the leader of Liberal Democract Party in the UK promised the then Ruling party in Malawi UDF that he was going to unearth Dr HKB funds in the UK Banks which was aledged to be in millions of pounds .David Steel discovered that Dr HKB didn’t have the amount of money which was claimed that he had and afterwards he just kept quiet .

    So Mr Wright do enough research instead of this half baked story ,we Malawians know about the history of our nation and don’t need your lies to please us .

  7. Nthumbetupe says:

    ‘Che Captain’ you are the one who is fake. After Bingu was kicked out of COMESA he operated a minibus which he personally drove while in Lilongwe living in Area 15 with a Mr Namondwe who ended being Malawi envoy to China during Bingu’s rule. One day when his minibus had a tyre puncture at the junction to Bambino Secondary school he asked for my help to fix a spare tyre. After fixing the tyre he drove off promising he would me some cash later for my chibuku. Anyway he never did and I never met him thereafter.

  8. chibisa says:

    Captain Bingu was a minibus driver in Lilongwe after he was fired from Comesa. In other countries like South Africa mini bus drivers are called taxi drivers.
    Nick In Malawi we like and support people who steal. If Lutepo can decide to run for a president he can win!!!!!!!

  9. GRM says:

    It will need a very strong President to deal with this mentality. In Malawi everyone now want to reap where he did not sow. It is a mentality everywhere from house maid to her master to the office and to the Ministries’ headquarters. Drastic change management at the top will have ripple effect.

  10. tzbvxhn says:

    Academıcıans who are ınvested ın mundane stuff. We shouldnt expect anything from them.

  11. ma hope a stella gwengweya says:

    hahaha! look at those foolish women hiding their faces. pokudya ndalama za amphawi mumabisala? nyo

  12. Willie Chirwa says:

    Your last thought on Malawi’s modern history is quite brilliant because at the moment we only read the past and not the present. Our history in school should also tackle the present. However, some of your writings are not well researched therefore some critics will dwell much on that than the main fact

  13. Pat says:

    Was Bingu Pro of Tax? Ur too young my brother, please re- write ur story

  14. learnedmi says:

    Good narrative article but spoiled by visible distortion of facts. Search at COMESA for the right information.

  15. Mphwacge says:

    What these guys forget is that in 1992 through public mass support, we took away everything the MCP and Young Pioneers scammed from us. We are also capable of taking away what has been stolen from us now. The big mansions In Area 9,10,43,44 and elsewhere will be run down when the next revolution wave comes, and is not too far away. I can feel it in my veins.

  16. Kaka says:

    Everything else seems to make sense. But point of correction on Kamuzu. Kamuzu was a big time farmer for more than 30 years in a country where farming was really flourishing under him. This made him rich through legitimate means. And those who imitated him in terms of farming got equally rich. It is after 1994 that people started getting rich without sweating as the nation got poorer and poorer

  17. Mwethu says:

    @#1, yes Bingu used to drive his own minibus on the Likuni Lilongwe Old Town Road, he is spot on describing him as former taxi driver! Just go to Bwandilo and ask about Bingu you will told his stories when he used to self drive a minibus until Bakili felt pity on the former international economist and gave him a position as Deputy Governer RBM and later as Deputy Minister of Economic Planning. So everything in the article is very true and also well written.

  18. Njegame Syaosimo says:

    Response to No.1.
    I think you do not understand the English language otherzise you are chewalising it. A taxi is not only that small car that a opassenger would pay for a ride. In countries like RSA a mini bus or Zimbabwe Kombi is also known as Taxi. Yes Bingu was driving Lilongze-Likuni mini bus also known as taxi. Yes the writer is correct to call bingu wa mutharika a taxi driver.
    Chizungutu ichi.

  19. Truck says:

    THATS WHY MALAWI ITS FAILING TO DEVELOP TOO MUCH CASHGATE JUST LOOK AT OUR NEXT DOOR MOZAMBIQUE ARE BOOMING WITH DEVELOPMENTS MORE THAN US YOU CANT BELIEVE THAT MOZAMBIQUE WAS IN A WAR FOR LONG TIME.I CRY MY BELOVED COUNTRY MALAWI LETS STOP CASHGATE PLEASE AND RETURN CASHGATE MONEY BACK TO GOVERNMENT SO THAT THEY CAN BUY MEDICINES AND PAY GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES .

  20. BBC says:

    We also need a dislike icon to discredit useless comments.

  21. .... says:

    Kodi Mary Kachale ayamba liti kukamba mulandu wa K577 billion zimene zinabedwa ndi DPP?

  22. captain says:

    U are not a good writer. Bingu taxi driver? Am not DPP but u are fake writer

Comments are closed.