DPP grills Kumwembe in Mphwiyo shooting case

Case of Shooting of former budget director in the ministry of Finance, Paul Mphwiyo has now entered defence where first accused Mcdonald Kumwembe ex Malawi Defence Force soldier, second accused businessman Pika Manondo and former justice minister Raphael Kasambara are now defending themselves on charge of attempted murder and conspiracy to commit murder.

Kumwembe:  Cross examined

Kumwembe: Cross examined

The matter which is being heard at Lilongwe High Court with Justice Michel Mtambo presiding, entered into defence Thursday 11th December with State top prosecutor Mary Kachale cross examining first accused Kumwembe for the whole day on how he is connected with the shooting

Mozambique Trip

DPP: You alleged that you were in Mozambique when the incident happened, can you tell this Court how did you travel? Mode of transport.

Kumwembe: I travelled on a minibus to border there we normally use bicycles to connect to town and get a car and that’s what even my passport shows.

DPP: How much money did you have when going out?

Kumwembe: Mmmmmm its way back and couldn’t remember up to date after all this period

DPP: Roughly if you can estimate 

Kumwembe: Around K850, 000

DPP: Does the law allow you to travel outside with those huge sums of Malawi kwacha?

Kumwembe: I’m not here to talk whether it’s legal or not and that question is irrelevant since we’re talking of my trip not what the laws says on money issue. And it’s not my first trip you can check my passport I’m frequent traveller to Mozambique since it’s where I go to order goods for my business.

DPP: But you came there without any goods which you say you went to buy, is it true?

Kumwembe: Yes, I sold them there to Zimbabwean who bought me in dollars and that’s the dollars you found with me in my wallet, in fact I have been doing that for sometimes since I can order and sale right there to Zimbabweans and that’s business you don’t say I will not sale t because I want to sale at my home country.

DPP: Now when coming back from Malawi on 14th September as you alleged, who was the first person to meet at Dedza border?

Kumwembe: I met Pika Manondo (one of the suspect) and it shows I spoke to him through MTN line from Mozambique

DPP: What was the meeting for, what did he tell you there?

Kumwembe: That day he was supposed to give me cash and he was telling me the boss (Mphwiyo) who was supposed to give us cash has been shot so we wait and hear how it ends

DPP: What time was this?

Kumwembe: mmm can’t tell but it has to be between 10 and 11

DPP: Now you said you left your phone with your friend Luciano Chikumbutso, why?

Kumwembe: I left it for him to be communicating with Pika to give him my money

DPP: where was he?

Kumwembe: I assume he was in Zomba where I was staying with him but he was supposed to be in Lilongwe to take my cash from Pika on the day I arrived through Dedza border

DPP: But if he was in Zomba or going to Lilongwe the call log shows your number was at Silver Stadium [in Lilongwe] around 6 am 

Kumwembe: I don’t know that since he never told me that he is in Lilongwe. I’m talking of the program which I was told and knew about. He was supposed to be in Lilongwe.

Luciano Chikumbutso:

The DPP also quizzed Kumwembe on the connections and how he knew Luciano Chikumbutso. The state read Kumwembe’s affidavit which indicated that Chikumbutso was his cousin as he was his mother sister’s son.

But when he was asked to explain, Kumwembe refused that Luciano was his blood brother, saying he is his brother as they have been friends since their youthful life and they have lived together as such.

The top prosecutor then quizzed Kumwembe to confess he lied to court that he was his brother but he denied saying he meant he is his brother looking at how long their friendship has been.

State produced a letter allegedly written by Luciano father and sister refusing that their son who is based in South Africa was in the country by that time, saying his son left the country January early in 2012 and since then he has never been in the country that he even failed to matted his mother funeral ceremony.

Kumwembe disputed the authenticity of the letter, saying it was not written by the father as a CID officer Mr Matanki went to the parents and threatened them to disown his affidavit and that the parents wrote that in fear.

But he maintained Luciano was in the country by that time and he is the one who was using his number when he was in Mozambique.

Kumwembe also alleged in the court that CID top official Mr Matanki went to see him while in prison on 5th October 2015 and also visited the father at his house in Area 25 and took him to Area 30 till 7pm and it’s possible he was forced to write the letter.

Pika relationship and MCP work 

The state also quizzed Kumwembe on his relationship with Manondo

DPP: how do you know Pika Manondo? 

Kumwembe: I know him as my business partner whom we were working together for party business; he is the one who was going to get our payments to Mphwiyo and Osward Lutepo [cashgate convict] on work issues.

DPP: Where does he live?

Kumwembe: Area 47 in Lilongwe

DPP: How much money did he give you at the border?

Kumwembe: I can’t remember but it has to be around K700, 000

DPP: What was this money for?

Kumwembe: It was part payment of our work which I was heading to the south to disturb the MCP party which was to ensure that Lovemore Munlo [former Chief Justice] was not elected as MCP president at the convention as he was a threat.

Kumwembe said he met Manondo in Balaka when the then Head of State Joyce Banda was conducting a political rally at Toleza where she was welcoming former UDF secretary general Kennedy Makwangwala into the Peoples Party where they were told to destabilise MCP convention by decampaigning Munlo.

He said Pika was the one going to get cash from Mphwiyo and Lutepo and the he was distributing it to other operatives.

Shooting expertise

The state also asked Kumwembe, a former Malawi Defence Force solider, what he meant by saying the person who shot Mphwiyo was an amateur in shooting. Kumwembe told the court that the way he was trained he can shoot the target stationed or moving from 300 metres and not miss the target and as such he couldn’t miss Mphwiyo on 5 metres.

The state also asked him if he has ever shot a person and never miss but Kumwembe said he has never done it but at the Army they were doing the target training and as shooting trained expert he couldn’t miss the target.

Meanwhile the State is expected to continue with cross examination Friday with Manondo.

Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

Please share this Article if you like Email This Post Email This Post

More From Nyasatimes

More From the World

24 thoughts on “DPP grills Kumwembe in Mphwiyo shooting case”

  1. DR.CASHGATE says:

    Paul Mphwiyo knows the whole story and he must tell the whole nation what actually happened , who shot him and why he was shot ,, atiunzeso anthu omwe anapanga chiwembu chonse . I can see Paul kuwomberedwa ulele !!

  2. Concerned citizen says:

    The trueth is already proven i dont see the reason why these issues are brought now and fourth

    God bless Malawi

    lets just leave this and start working towards ceasing poverty we are facing

  3. Mbuya says:

    I dont see ve defence of Kumwembe here amazikola yekha

  4. Stinking Idiot says:

    Bwana politicians behind the scenes are rotten. Its not worth debating.

  5. Gadabwali says:

    Nyasa Times, continue giving us verbatim reporting of ths case, ikusangalatsa ukamawerenga although mafunso ena frm the DPP are not making sense. One tends to wonder whether the DPP wll win ths case. Kumwembe, I like the way you are answering, ukuzitsata!

  6. ramsay snow is just misunderstood says:

    kodi sentencing ya savala ili pati? ine ndayamba kuwona kuti anthu inu mukuikoka milanduyi kuti muzingodya ma night allowance. nyo!

  7. I think azungu akutiseka. Why waisting tax money when you know you are playing a game. Who are you fooling? Donors or Malawians? Malawians when are you going to solvena case. These Cash Gaters ar enjoying money theystole some of them have even moved the money they had hidden to other countries. No one of them will be convicted because they will review people in the DDP and other parties. Lets just forget and start from fresh to fight corruption of tomorrow. Donors will hold their money GOOD. No more stealling donors money. Who will miss that money those who are waiting to steal forex. That is now they are taking US$ 75 for every foreigner. But that is not enough. How many foreigners who come to Malawi? All Mawians are responsible for what is going on in the country. Malaians like bribe and begging. Ask the airport. Personnels there beg for coca cola shameful. I have never experienced that in Ethiopia of elsewhere. Mphwiyo comes in suits and body guard like a king. What do you think is that. Just close the cases we are tired of this. I knew that this if DDP comes back no Cash Gate will be solved. APM is afriad of his own case and that is why he has aken out from Cash Gate of Goodal Gondwe, Bakili Muluzi, Calliati, and all DDP members. Do you think donors will give money. They are not stupid as we are. Corruption was created by aid. As money started coming in into African government the leaders started getting rich by using the aid money. Look at them. How can they be so rich than leaders in the west.? What does Malawi have to make a leader so rich like Bingu was. A man he has to build his own house as his grave yard. Not even Michael Jacksson has such a grave. Is Bingu happy there he is? A black man thinks different. Wasting money which could a clinic in his area. I am sorry I have no respect for an African whether educated or not. Look at those who are educated? They are the ones spoilling Africa. Young ones lik Kasambala, Mphwiyo, Pika etc are thieves. What and where are their children going to live when they spoil Africa/Malawi.

  8. wawa says:


  9. Zelda says:

    Mphwiyo was shot without a miss its just that God saved his life for us to know the truth, so it was indeed you Mr. Kumwembe, because you did not miss at all

  10. Paka Bush says:

    Kodi Madam DPP nanunso mukuchedwetsa bwanji? Judge Michael Mtambo already have the ruling on these criminals….Aliyense ali ndi sentence yake….Tayambani ya Bambo Mphwiyo akalowe mnzawo Lutepo asavutike yekha…..

  11. Nyika justice says:

    good defence mr kumwembe. light at the end of the tunnel

  12. Nyika justice says:

    Very good defence mr kumwembe. light at the end of the tunnel

  13. Olo says:

    Yes! Mr Kumwembe you can’t miss someone from 5meters! You didn’t miss the target on Mr Phwiyo! You were on target but Mr Phwiyo is just lucky guy and thanks to dr Ntaba for serving phwiyo’ life before taken to South Africa to have bullets which you mr Kumwembe didn’t miss been removed!

  14. Olo says:

    Everyone knows that Mr Phwiyo was shot and his life was first served by dr Ntaba before going to South Africa to have bullets removed from his body! So yes mr Kumwembe didn’t miss him since he was so close. 2..if you are a real business man How can you forget the amount of cash which Pika give you on the border, how can you know that you are making profits or not? Zoti muwina mulandu imenewu ndakaika.

  15. Bikiloni Nachipanti says:

    Idi Amin said to be spy is criminal and if you are caught spying you will have to face military tribunal without wasting time. You do not need to spend hours discussing one person. All you need to do is a shot cut..

    Government is wasting alot of money in the prosecution of these criminals. All the need is a shot cut basi, like what Idi Amin said to his cabinet ministers. These people need to be prosecuted in a Idi Amin’s military tribunal foresure.

  16. kkkkkkk adakakhala gwanda or aleke banda anyamata awa adapita ku ng’ona basi. Chibwana chakula.

  17. Willie Chimseu says:

    But Mr Mphwiyo has got alot to tell the nation of Malawi. Mcp , cashgate & shooting. Koma sanadzishoote ekha ameneyu game itamukulira?

  18. bumbu nchuma says:

    keep it up nyasatimes

  19. Chimlomo cha Petulo Mathanyula toothless says:

    some questions were really irrelevant. My observation: So PP was wasting our tax money even in very stupid dealings? Disturbing MCP elections really? What was it that JB feared in Lovemore Munlo becoming president of MCP? JB sucks no wonder she is on the run now – self inflicted exile, stupid woman!!! Typical of southerners kaduka too much and zianthu zimenezi zawononga Malawi kwambiri. No wonder God is punishing you with floods! Foolish idiots!

  20. General says:

    Well that’s the way to answer MR KUMWEMBE these courts of ours are too corrupt and they don’t do justice at all, am just watching them

  21. Boyi says:

    Achikulire a Kumwembe. Koma nkhani ya shooting of Mphwiyo yaononga ndalama zambiri from this impoverished nation that can not even afford fuel for ambulances, can not feed its people, can not build classrooms for its pupils, can not buy medicines nor repair medical equipment.

  22. Nankununkha sadzimva says:

    Shooting Mphwiyo was a bad battle but good war to combat corruption. The guy was the epicenter of corrupt activities. It makes me sick to hear Joyce Banda touting him as at the helm of corruption busting. May be because she appointed him to do the job of stealing for PP. She borrowed the stealing tactic from the DPP. No wonder she lost elections

Comments are closed.