Jumbe, Bwanali bid to remove Justice Kachale fail: Trial April 23

Judge Chifundo Kachale will continue to preside the case in the Lilongwe Magistrate Court the trial of former ministers of Friday Jumbe (Finance) and Phillip Bwanali (Sports  Culture), who were implicated in the theft of K11 million from the Ministry of Sports in 2004 after the High Court dismissed an application by two former ministers to have Kachale removed as presiding magistrate.

Back in court: Jumbe (L) and Bwanali

Back in court: Jumbe (L) and Bwanali

High Court judge  Kachale is presiding as chief resident magistrate because he originally handled the case in that capacity.

Jumbe and Bwanali launched a legal challenge through lawyer Manuel Theu that as a judge Kachale had no jurisdiction to handle the case because it was a lower court matter.

Theu also questioned the marital status of Kachale who is married to Director of Public Prosecutions Mary Kachale arguing that she is also prosecuting the case.

But Kachale trashed the challenge arguing Section 5 (a) of the Courts Act gives him the power to preside over the case and that the chief resident magistrate herself requested him to continue with the case upon handing over the case files to her office.

Kachale ruled that there “no legitimate justification on impartiality of the case.”

He said: “ This case was not revived after my wife was appointed DPP, the record will show for itself. This case was revived in November 2013 long before my wife was appointed DPP in July 2014.”

Kachale also explained that the case is being prosecuted on behalf of office of Anti Corruption Bureau (ACB) as outsourced the prosecution of the case to G.D Liwimbi and Partners who have put lawyer Gabriel Chembezi on the case and not office Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) as argued by the defence.

The court has set April 23 and 24 this year as dates for commencement of the trial.

The case has resumed seven years after the two former ministers and chairperson of the Sports and Culture Trust Fund, Vincent Mpaluko, were found with a case to answer on charges ranging from theft by a public servant, misuse of office and gross negligence by a public officer to obtaining money by false pretence.

Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

Please share this Article if you like Email This Post Email This Post

More From the World

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Garu Wa Garu

There is something wrong with this picture. It does not sound right: HUSBAND,WIFE. Aaaa NO let us be fair here. What if the judge dies (I am not wishing her bad) will they not assign another judge to the case. They should fight for this.

Boyd Kilembey

The professionalism of the Kachales must not be doubted. If the suspects think everybody in that position would be influencing the case, thyen alemba mmadzi. Just concerntrate on defending the case.


A jumbe mumayesa DPP ikutetezani pothetsa kachipani kanu? Choti mudziwe ndi choti DPP siikukufunani inu mungodziphatikira. Udindo wa CEO ku Development Bank upita kwa enanso poti i nu Central Bank yauzidwa kuti ikupangeni reject. In ndinali pa meeting imeneyo.

A Bwanali ndiye munangofera za ini. Kusaukanso kwakupezani. Mukasavaiva ku ndende?

Wadya Kake alibe mbiri
Wadya Kake alibe mbiri

A Bwanali nde anasauka olo ya lawyer ali nayo? Ndakaika mmene akupemphera mowa pa Casablanca


Alah zoopusa basi bwanji mukusiya mbava za ma lawyer kumayimilira anthu pa milandu ya cashgate enanso mpakana kumaziyimilira wokha…inu mukungoyangana

jean jella

Koma kachale is a joke
Why insist on hearing this case.
He should be moved to the commercial court. He can’t preside cases while the wife os dpp


Smilling thieves…koma ku Malawi?



Gwira Bango Madzi Angakutenge
Gwira Bango Madzi Angakutenge

Seems like the Kachales are here to bring change in the judicial system. It is time we stood by their side. All the best MrAnd Mrs Kachale.

Kamuzu Banda

But seriously, I imagine where, the wife is prosecuting and the husband is hearing the case. I would urge Jumbe and Bwanali to take their complaints further. This is not to say, they didn’t steal but it doesn’t just sound right…kaya anzanga

More From Nyasatimes