Kasambara quiz rebuttal witness for State in Mphwiyo shooting

Private practice lawyer Ralph Kasambara – Senior Counsel –  one of the accused in the Paul Mphwiyo shooting case on Tuesday quizzed rebuttal witnesses paraded by State prosecutors.

Trial by error

Kasambara: Quizes rebuttal witness

Kasambara is accused of conspiring to murder former budget director Mphwiyo alongside former Malawi Defence Force (MDF) soldier Macdonald Kumwembe and businessperson Pika Manondo who also face an extra charge of attempting to murder the former budget director.

First rebuttal witness was Luciano Chiumbuzo who was exposed by making inconsistencies during cross examination.

“Did you use Mr Kumwembe’s phone in 2013? Did you visit Mr Kumwembe at Maula Prison? “asked Kasambara.

Chiumbudzo replied “no” to both questions.

In his affidavit, Kumwembe said he was in Mozambique at the time Mphwiyo, then budget director in the Ministry of Finance, was shot outside the gate of his Area 43 residence in Lilongwe on September 13 2013.

Kumwembe said while he was in Mozambique on the material day, his mobile phone was in Malawi and was used by Chiumbudzo.

Chiumbudzo was also pressed on inconsistencies in his testimony, saying the events happened “a long time ago and it is very difficult to remember.”

Said Kasambara: “Very simple and straightforward Mr Chiumbudzo; did you meet Kumwembe when you came back from Botswana? Yes or no.”

In his response, Chiumbudzo said: “I am sorry if I seem not to answer as per your request. I need to explain so that the Malawi nation hears me well and good. It is also my right to be heard just as you are being heard. Please do not put words in my mouth.”

Kasambara further accused Chiumbudzo of stealing a Mercedes Benz in Botswana and that he was deported following the theft.

But Mtambo asked Kasambara to provide proof of all the allegations.

The second witness was Luciano’s brother who said his brother was in South Africa during Mphwiyo shooting.

Asked by Kasambara that Luciano was in Malawi and roaming on his South African mobile number, he said: “No he cannot roam. We could have purchased a Malawian number.”

Kasambara asked the court to be allowed to parade witness to counter the State’s rebuttal witness. The Director of Public Prosecution Mary Kachale objected to the application but Judge Micheal Mtambo granted Kasambala’s wish.

He said he will only parade Kumwembe to answer some questions based on statements made by Luciano’s brother.

Manondo and Kumwembe were found with a case to answer on the charge of conspiracy to commit murder. The two are also jointly charged with Kasambara on the charge of conspiracy to commit a crime.

Gun-shot survivor Mphwiyo actually stated in all three statements presented to court that he did not know who shot him and had no idea who may have wanted to harm him.

Mphwiyo’s shooting at the gate on his Area 43 residence in Lilongwe is believed to have exposed Cashgate, the plunder of public resources at Capital Hill.

Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

Please share this Article if you like Email This Post Email This Post

More From Nyasatimes

More From the World

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Lanken chasowa
Guest
Lanken chasowa
4 months 16 days ago

First jail your stupid peter mathanyula.the big thief.

kokota
Guest
kokota
4 months 16 days ago

Kodi a mtambo osangolamula kuti uyu milomo yake ikufiyilayu aphedwe bwanji nditha kusangala kwambiri bwampini ameneyu wafika ponyasa

JJ
Guest
JJ
4 months 16 days ago

This is a useless article. Why can’t you tell us in detail what the witnesses said? And then tell us how Kasambara did his so quiz rebuttal in detail. By the way, I know the reason why you are telling us this quarter truth. While all news outlets in Malawi reported about the proceedings in the court on Monday when Chiumbuza and his friends stood as state witnesses, Nyasatimes did not do the same. The reason is simple. Only unpatriotic citizen can defend a criminal like …

Bima Matheza
Guest
Bima Matheza
4 months 16 days ago

These thugs are together & are just fooling the Public

Kanyimbi
Guest
Kanyimbi
4 months 16 days ago

Palibe cha nzeru chomwe chalembedwapo apa

Bungulu
Guest
Bungulu
4 months 16 days ago

Fed up to the bone… Today Kasambala this… Tomorrow Kasambala that… CASHGATE. Ndatopa ine.

LAW101
Guest
LAW101
4 months 16 days ago

Senior Council? Umbuli muzasiya liti??

Mbola Za malamulo
Guest
Mbola Za malamulo
4 months 16 days ago

Raphael Kasambara is a big crook! Take what Oswald Lutepo said and lock up all the culprits. With time these criminals are sending away the money that was stolen and have given most of their assets to their relatives for fear of the after month of the case. A thief or criminal will never say Yes I did! Amakana chinthu chili mmanja~!

chibweya joe
Guest
chibweya joe
4 months 16 days ago

Kasambara has mot been convicted and no one can call him a thief. After all he is much wider than some of you making these allegations. Wait for the courts to determine.

Thyolo Thava
Guest
Thyolo Thava
4 months 16 days ago

Izi zatopetsa abale! M’malo molimbana ndi ma susbstative issues, mukulimbana ndi Chiumbudzo ndi abale ake??? Mukulimbana za ziiiiiii! Ife tikungofuna kumva mayankho to these questions:

1. Anawombera Mphwiyo ndani? Chifukwa chani?
2. Kodi kuwomberedwa kwa Mphwiyo kukukhudzana ndi Cashgate? Ngati kukukhudzana, Mphwiyo anatengapo mbali yanji pa Cashgate?

Mukayankha mafunso amenewa tidziwa mayankho a timafunso tina tonse tokhudza Joyce Banda, Oswald Lutepo, Ralph Kasambara, the Manondo Brothers, etc

wpDiscuz