Ansah-led MEC lacked openness, its decisions questionable – ConCourt

The Constitutional Court  (ConCourt) in a ruling in the controversial presidential poll results that saw the re-election of President Peter Mutharika has  stated the Malawi Electoral Commission (MEC( led by Justice Jane Ansah was not fair and open in handling electoral complaints.

Ansah and MEC commisisoner
DPP lawyers Samuel Tembenu,  Charles Mhango and  at the Court-pic by Lisa Kadango
UTM President Saulosi Chilima arrives at the ConCourt-pic by Lisa Kadango
MHRC official and MCP MP Ulemu Msungama arrives at the Court-pic by Lisa Kadango

In a ruling read by Judge Ivy Kamanga on behalf of the five judges’ panel, the court finds that aggrieved parties submitted their complaints to Chief Elections Officer Sam Alfandika who testified that he forwarded the complaints to Commissioners with recommendations.

The ConCourt noted that the decision were written and signed by Alfandika and the aggrieved parties were not summoned and heard by the Commissioners.

“There was no occasion in this case where the petitioners were given audience by the commissioners. All complaints were given to the Chief Elections Officer],” the court observed.

It said the Ansah led MEC lacked openness in handling of complaints.

“Resolutions were written by Mr Alfandika and he also communicated the decisions. It is therefore questionable whether the decisions were made by Mr Alfandika or the Commissioners,” the court said.

The court noted that the absent of commissioners to testify in the case was so blatant, as no commissioner swore a sworn statement.

ConCourt said MEC should always work like a tribunal or a small court.

On powers to delegate, the court said delegation has to be reviewed in entire context of the statutes, pointing out that he powers of the commissioners are derived from the Constitution and deals with rights of voters and candidates

The Court has said .the commission could not delegate its quasi-judicial powers and functions which result in making legally-binding decision that could be appealable – such powers could not be delegated to the Chief Elections Officer.

“Minutes of any body are not an official record and evidence of whatever transpired at such meetings,” says the court.

The court said Alfandika was not the right person to tell the court what transpired at Commissioners’ meeting “even if he was present in such meetings” as he not a decision maker according to the law.

“No reasonable constitutional body would delegate powers to its Chief Elections Officer like MEC did,” judge Kamanga said reading the ruling.

She pointed that the law does not recognise the Chief Elections Officer as the key decision maker on electoral issues.

The court said the delegation of power to Alfandika was “unreasonable, absurd and unconstitutional.”

The Court said there is no letter or any evidence that MEC delegated its powers to the Chief Elections Officer therefore the commissioners were the only persons who could have explained to court why they arrived certain decisions as a tribune.

The losing candidates alleged that the electoral process, especially the way the results were handled, was full of irregularities.

The court said it has used both quantitative and qualitative method to come up with its ruling, looking at whether the numbers and processes affected the election.

As the judgement is being delivered many people are indoors, but supporters of the main parties are expected to flood the streets into the main urban centres for celebrations whichever way the result will go.

Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

Sharing is caring!

Follow us in Twitter
10 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Arrogance
Arrogance
1 year ago

A chill of disquiet tingles down my spine when I ponder on the fact that Jane Ansah is actually a justice of the Supreme Court of Appeal. Really? Your Lordship Jane Ansah, your colleagues on the bench in ConCourt have completely torn up your arguments about you not finding any irregularities in the elections process. The ConCourt judges have intelligently, logically and wisely given the reasons why they have arrived at THE VERDICT. Your Lordship Jane Ansah, you yourself should have been the one to advise your fellow commissioners on the finer points of the law regarding constitutional and statutory… Read more »

Wachiona Ndani
Wachiona Ndani
1 year ago

If Jane Ansah had resigned when she was being called to do so, the violent protests that subsequently ensued would not have happened, the deep political polarisation in an already divided Malawi would not have reared its ugly head, the Malawi Police “cadets ” would not have raped innocent and helpless village women kwa Msundwe, the … er… oh! the list goes on and on…

Malawi belong to the citizens.

Court judgement woyeee,UTM woyeee, MCP woyeee and DPP and MEC no woyeee.kkkkkk.

Forgive them
Forgive them
1 year ago

Kuswakuswa Ali pompano wasintha dzina ameneyu kkkkkkk,anthu isakonda dziko lawo ngati jane kkkkk ,Mulungu Siena blue mudziwe zimenezi

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
1 year ago

Iwe mwana wa satana jane ansah anthu amakuuza koma makani ndiyeno pano ulemu onse painu watha chifukwa Malawi amaonongeka ndikusamva kwako kuyambila lero uleke kupephera mu dzina la Mlengi chifukwa waonekela poyera kuti ulibe chikondi pa dziko la Malawi 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥ukuyatse mwana wasatana iwe uloya wobera aphawi mfiti iwe 🔥🔥🔥🙏🏿

Piper
Piper
1 year ago

Ooh Maigot !!

Mndinda Boy
Mndinda Boy
1 year ago
Reply to  Piper

Was this to say Oh my God?

mpanda
mpanda
1 year ago

I justice jane mayemu ansah declare my tippex resignation congratulations kuswakuswa kkkkk where are you hiding

Achiswe'.'
1 year ago

Ansah’s chickens have come home to roost. Time to pack your bags, Jane and head off into the sunset. Bye, bye!

WaWa
WaWa
1 year ago

If you have not done so yet APM start packing. All those cronies of yours will disappear. No more money from corruptly awarded contracts. It’s dog eat dog this game of politics Bwana Peter.

Read previous post:
ConCourt says Malawi electoral laws does not give MEC adequate time to resolve disputes

In  reading of the judgement in the presidential elections nullificationcase at the Constitutional Court in Lilongw,  lead Judge Healy Potani...

Close