Malawi VP Chilima blasts engineer for poor work at K290m Tengani dyke: ‘Waste of resources’
Vice-President Saulos Chilima on Tuesday blasted Shire River Basin Management Programme BRL Engineers for constructing a substandard K290 million dyke which would not protect the people as intended.
Chilima, who visited the 823 metre dyke constructed along the Nkhande River in the area of Senior Chief Tengani in the district (Nsanje), expressed dissatisfaction with the way the dyke had been constructed, saying it would not protect the communities.
The aim of government putting up the dyke along Nkhande River was to protect people and their property in the event that the river floods.
Chilima was seen charged, demanding answers from the BRL officials on why they spent government money on something which was not sustainable.
In an interview, the Vice President said he was worried and not happy with the work as it did not reflect well on government’s efforts in developing the nation.
“I must say the truth that the dike is of substandard. I did not expect to see work like what I have seen today here. Even though I am not an engineer, I am justified to call the construction work substandard,” said Chilima.
The Vice President even told the BRL Engineers that the construction works should be reworked to reflect the real purpose of the dike, which is to protect the communities from the flooding water.
Chilima even regretted to have travelled a long distance to inspect something which was not worth the visit.
“I am really regretting that we have even spent resources to inspect something which will not protect our people. The project will not help our people.
“Therefore, we need to sit down and discuss so that the works should be reworked. This is a death trap to people because if the dike is washed away, then it will negatively affect on the communities,” said Chilima.
Nsanje Central Constituency Member of Parliament, who is also Minister of Labour, Youth, Sports and Manpower Development, Francis Kasaila in whose constituency the dyke has been constructed, also expressed displeasure on the substandard works done.
Kasaila said the work is as good as having done nothing on the ground as it will not protect lives and property of the communities.
“We are not happy with the way the dike has been constructed. I and Senior Chief Tengani have been seeking audience with the BRL engineers but they have been shunning us. We wanted to give them advice which could have made the work to be perfected,” explained Kasaila.
One of the BRL leading engineers, Anati Jere, agreed to sentiments made by the Vice President over the substandard works on the Tengani dike.
Jere, however, said the amount of money spent resonated with the works which had been done on the dike.
“As the Vice President is putting it on the construction works, I agree with him. The work which has been done is worth the money spent or planned. However, as the Vice President has put it, we will have to sit down and see,” said Jere
Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :
Everyone should know that Anati Jere is not an engineer by training. He did land development and was with illovo Nchalo as farm farm manager where he demonstrated lack of management skills resulting to consistent low tonnage of cane from his section.This man can’t perform. This country is failing to move forward because we choose incompetent individuals to guard our resources. Government may have good plans to develop this nation but if this trends continues, then it’s not wrong to say that the project’s are just a bait to swindle tax payers money. The roads are poor, take an example of Linthipe-Thete road, very poor.
Secondly, Francis Kasaila is too incompetent and hypocrite. He is a civil engineer by profession and this substandard duke is in his constituency, all along he never spotted this poor quality? Does he monitor development projects in his area or has enough with his ministerial position. He even had the guts to invite the vice president to witness this mess? What a theoretical civil engineer Kasaila is!
Chilima for President 2019
A Kasaila mwavomereza just because a VP ayankhulapo, we know munapita kuseli kukatenga part of the money and the contractor being in business had no choice but to put up a sub standard dyke. Nanunso munachita ka DYKEGATE kanu. Like father like son.
Where was the supervisionfrom the government during the construction? Naonso a kunsaira amvekere eeeh it’s substandard, him being an MP for the area why was he able to track quality of the project implemented in his area. This is shithole
It is unfortunate that you are working with thieves and that should not surprise you. You chose to support thieves and you are shithole too.
Finally someone who is speaking up on mediocre construction projects happening in malawi. Now speak against the construction of the new btz stadium. We dont need it! Not with so many priorities laying around. We cant think of constructing a stadium ahead of roads, power and hospital infrastructure. Its absurd!
If my analysis is correct Chilima’s message is not directed at the contractor, butKasaila whose ministry was supposed to be supervising the construction works. I tend to agree with some commentators that part of the money was given to DPP. This is why in 2019 people in the Lower Shire will not give any vote to DPP and if anything Kasaila must be careful, he may not retain his Parliamentary seat. Utesi.
Which Kasaila Ministry is this you are talking about? Former (Foreign affairs) or Sports…?
Shut hole country
Bravo Klaus, That’s why I like you because you can change Malawi within a year you are capable to help our Mdala Peter but the lazy ministers like Katsaila they dwelling in cheating the president. Kweeekweeesani ma yinjiniya awo adzaululula
Mwamuona President withu, uyu ndiye president wachitukuko. Ung’onoung’ono. N the ndrama izo zaluta muthumba la nduna iyo yazamiseu. Follow up ndiamene akumatiluzitsa kapena kutitukwanitsa.
I am not an Engineer but I surely know what goes into such a project. We are talking of lots of reinforcement steel, cement, quarry stone, etc stretching across 823 metres. Thats just a little short of a Kilometer. And the dyke has to have a considerable deep foundation and a good height to serve its purpose. Now you don’t need to be genius to see that, that is not a work of 290m. Simple mathematics will show you substandard output obviously. Question is, is this the money that was initially budgeted for this project? Are you sure the project consultants did not highlight to government what the project will require? I don’t know of any engineer who could have done a good job with that kind of money. And my guess is, this engineer was desperate for a contract. Any competent contractor I know of would not have taken this job.
Why did the contractor accept the project he surely knew that he could not do at the said price. You and me do not know what is specified in this dyke. Is it earth made or concrete is involved or what about it’s size. I’m also a professional contractor and a construction expert for that matter but substandard work should not be blamed on the cost here because the contractor was fully aware of what was involved in signing the contract.
I am sorry to say I fail to see the works of professional contractors and construction experts of Malawi origin. Either they aren’t there or they are fake. If a doctor or a nurse is inefficient their certificates are withdrawn. There is rampant ignominious engineer results in Malawi, Isn’t there a body that can recall these bastard self acclaimed dubious engineers?
Once again, VP Chilima tells it like it is. An honest man in politics is a rare breed.
Bwana engineer zoona you are saying thé amount certified is worth thé substandard. Apapa professionalism ndi 0/10. Why pay for thé substandard in thé fort place?. MA engineer a China akumalawi please be serious.
This where some of us miss the way the old guard (ngwazi) governed,construction of government projects were not done without proper tendering process,the winning bidder was given a time frame after being vetted by the ministry of works and supplies,though satisfied with the results of this vetting the ministry also became supervisors of the project over and above the consulting engineering firm,that way projects were monitored stage by stage.lero mungosiyira contractor yekha wosachitidwa vett,alibe mbiri ya nchito yowoneka yomwe anagwirapo ngati reference and you expect to get a good deal,you in a country where the legal system is questionable,you must be (WISHING).
Don’t blame the engineers here.half of that amount was given back to the ruling party hence the contractor was forced to do a wishy washy job because he wanted to make profits too,so since Chilima didn’t know that some of the money is used for campaign from the dyke,but kasaila can’t fool us here that being a full and trusted minister of Peter can fail to meet the engineers.My warning to the engineers and the contractors, is that mufera za eni!Ask Chaponda,Lutepo,Kasambara just to mention a few. Ma politicians ngoipa zikavuta amakutaya chiiiiii.
Kasaila you are also a civil engineer and you didn’t see this in your own constituency?
Well done VP. We need more of this. Billions going down the drain on sub standard projects.
Atumbuka a kuchinyani a chewa. Look at quality of works in the north-roads, water systems even electricity- vs work in the south? Achewa kupusa, can you find a chewa doing major construction work in the north or supervising major works?????? Anganya aba ndalama apa wakamangira country houses.
Iwe, Jere of BRL who was interviewed is a pure tumbuka mbava. This reminds me of tumbuka teachers spending all the time giving PE lessons instead of mathematics, biology and physics with chemistry to achawa children during Kamuzu era and that is why they were expelled to teach in their thengereland.
You guys in Malawi are jokes. How do you give work worth Millions to Mickley mouse construction companies with no track records. Are you really surprised. Engineers that have just passed exams off college shouldn’t be trusted with any serious work. This is happening everywhere from building roads to construction of public infrastructure . Malawian national l roads don’t even have proper drainage systems and who cares because there is too much thieving in the way the contracts are awarded. Simply don’t pay these liars
Of course that’s what it means to inspect if we are to go by it’s meaning. You inspect and discover that your work is good or bad. In this case something has gone wrong. Usually such projects are highly politicized and the contractor must have corrupted the entire village to reach that far.
If DPP puts Chilima as a Presidential candidate my vote goes to DPP otherwise am voting MCP 2019
This is another clear case of corruption or should i called it ‘dyke gate’. 290m ?? That work isnt even worthy 100m. Kasaila you might have inspected the work before inviting the VP. Why would you wait to be embarrassed?
In future try to follow up projects.
Who were the consulting engineers who must have certified the finished work.
Where were u Kasaila? I thought this is your area and you wait for VP to come to come and tell u that its substandard. I thought u r an engineer. Am sure u knw something plis ACB investigate this issue
Who nominated the contractor,what criteria do you use to appoint a contractor
By the way, what does BRL stand for?
Blasted Right Left civil engineers
Hahhahahahahahaha!!
Embaracing.. so called engineers.