Debate exposes running mates knowledge gaps, says governance expert

Presidential Running Mates Debate, an initiative of privately-owned Zodiak Broadcasting Station (ZBS),  has exposed some knowledge gaps amongst the  vice-presidential hopefuls in the various policies governing the sectors as well as the Constitution of Malawi, a governance expert has told Nyasa Times.

The three running mates who took part in the debate in Blantyre

Three of the presidential running mates in the May 21 2019 Tripartite Elections who  took part in the debate at Chichiri International Conference Centre widely known as Comesa Hall in Blantyre were Muhammed Sidik Mia of Malawi Congress Party (MCP), Frank Mwenifumbo of United Democratic Front (UDF) and Michael Usi from UTM Party.

Everton Chimulirenji of governing Democratic Progressive Party (DPP)  who chickened out in the first leg of debate in Lilongwe  did not show up again to fulfil a DPP statement that the party’s presidential candidate Peter Mutharika and his partner will not attend any debate.

Jerry Jana of People’s Party (PP) who attended last week’s session pulled out following his presidential candidate Joyce Banda’s withdrawal from the race.

Asked by Nyasa Times to rate them,  governance expert Makhumbo Munthali, said the trio  fared well – much improved from the previous debate.

“But they need to do more if they are indeed to take Malawi to the promised land,” he said.

During the session, Usi, Mia and Mwenifumbo tackled various topics ranging from health, gender and women empowerment, the economy, governance and access to justice and human rights, among others.

Asked to give rating in term of scores, Munthali  gave UDF’s Mwenefumbo 63%,  MCP’s Mia 60%  and  Michael Usi 60%.

In his critique to the debate, Munthali said it  was embarrassing to note that none of the the discussants  showed some awareness of the previous Constitutional review conference which culminated into the production of the Report on the Constitutional Review by the Law Commission which has a number of proposals of areas to amend in our Constitution.

“The expectation was that these running mates would be able to debate the proposed areas of amendment in the Constitution, and be able to share their insights.

“While there were some few instances where UDF’s running mate was able to refer to some policies including SDG and MGDS III, generally all the running mates demonstrated little knowledge of the existing policies guiding the thematic areas they were debating on,” observed governance commentator Munthali.

Besides,  Munthali continued that while tackling the issue of corruption the running mates  seemed to be more concentrated on removing the powers of the President to appoint the Director of Anti Corruption Bureau (ACB)  or recovering back on stolen public money, when in reality the issue of addressing corruption is complex with “prevention” (of corruption) being another important aspect towards curbing the vice.

“No running mate was able to state on how he would launch a national crusade against corruption,” pointed out Munthali.

Nonetheless, Munthali said the Blantyre session  was a much improved debate where the  running-mates were able to critique each other’s arguments while at the same time able to appreciate each other’s points of views where necessary.

“Yes, in some cases the debate got hot with some candidates almost losing their cool but then such moments were ably complemented with the civility which each of the three demonstrated towards the other as partly reflected on how they answered the last question. In fact it is such moments which made the debate exciting. You could even clearly see that the three running-mates were enjoying the debate,” he said.

On areas of improvement on the part of organisers, Munthali said time should be minimised as it was too long. A maximum of 2 hours for the running mates to debate is okay, he said.

Professor Wiseman Chijere Chirwa of the University of Malawi’s Chancellor College also described last night’s session as a real debate and not a question-and-answer affair as was the case at Bingu International Convention Centre (Bicc) in Lilongwe.

Next stop is Mzuzu on March 21.

Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
mtete
Guest
mtete

How else could Munthali rate the running mates other than a higher mark for Mwenifumbo? These political experts amaze me.

Anzelu ndi Anzelu
Guest
Anzelu ndi Anzelu

Mbuli zokha basi. They showed very little knowledge about the economy, government systems and protocol. Imagine someone talking about a federal system in Malawi. Federal systems are only necessary in complex geo/political situations which are not in our country. Stripping the immunity of a president means our president will spend more time in court than in the office. We have these silly myopic CSOs that live on rubble rousing and running to the courts on frivolous issues. These runningmate debates have shown that we have no better alternative.

Chilungamo
Guest
Chilungamo

What does geopolitical situation mean? You are vague yourself. Bwinobwinotu? Mbuli nkukhala inunomwe.
Ethnically and geographically Malawi is a very diverse country. People from Karonga, or Mchinji culturally are very different from those from Phalombe. It’s illogical therefore that the decision how they should be governed should be made by people far away from them. Just because the other tribe is overpopulated and do not care at all about how many kids to have in their lives.

Make Malawi Great
Guest
Make Malawi Great

where his rating based on tribalism? I don’t agree! Actually Mr Usi been putting these politicians to shame as far as grassroot knowlege is concern!!

Yasser Arafat Hamdani
Guest
Yasser Arafat Hamdani

Ma running mate ouma mitu awa. Anazidziwira kuti masavage

BigMan
Guest
BigMan

I agree the debate was too long, 2 to 3 hours with a break is sufficient although the audience was partly to blame.

Educated Northerner
Guest
Educated Northerner

Sure the audience was to blame. There were too much DPP supporters who solely participated to disturb. Shame!

Elikana mmbaya
Guest

Educated northerner ?? Choka mbuli iwe satana ndi amene mulubwezera mmambuyo mpoto nkumangozitama ndi pakamwa zochita gooooo !!