Let us prove we’re not ‘shitholes’ through action and not anger

“It is the role of good journalism to take on powerful abusers, and when powerful abusers are taken on, there’s always a bad reaction. So we see that controversy, and we believe that is a good thing to engage in”-Julian Assange-Australian Activist

The first entry of Crossing the Red Line came out on August 29, 2017 and in that entry, I took time to explain my mission and the mission of this column. And all my explanation was summed up by this quote from William Lloyd Garrison:

“I am aware, that many object to the severity of my language; but is there not cause for severity? I will be as harsh as truth, and as uncompromising as justice. On this subject, I do not wish to think, or speak, or write, with moderation. No! No! Tell a man whose house is on fire, to give a moderate alarm; tell him to moderately rescue his wife from the hand of the ravisher; tell the mother to gradually extricate her babe from the fire into which it has fallen; but urge me not to use moderation in a cause like the present. I am in earnest – I will not equivocate – I will not excuse – I will not retreat a single inch – AND I WILL BE HEARD.”

In short this column is inspired by William Lloyd Garrison who was a prominent American abolitionist, journalist, suffragist, and social reformer best remembered as one of the founders of the American Anti-Slavery Society (through his writing he promoted “immediate emancipation” of slaves in the United States). He also left an indelible mark in the history of America for his involvement in a number of causes-not only fighting against slavery-but he was also involved in a number of bodies fighting against the unfair system then. In the 1870s, Garrison also became a prominent voice for the woman suffrage movement.

In that entry, I personally invited everyone on board with a promise that if our politicians (in government or opposition) keep on crossing the red line with our lives; with our well-being; with our health systems; with our education; with our finances; and with everything that matter to move our Malawi forward; I will live Garrison’s promise.

And today, I have to add that Crossing the Red Line does not in any way support any political party; the writing here is solely to save the greater good of our nation. Crossing the Red Line is not here to ensure that any candidate or party wins the votes in 2019; its mission is to ensure that whoever wins in 2019 should be a leader or a party that sees the bigger picture more than personal gratification or enrichment. The mission of Crossing the Red Line is to be frank so that even the current ruling party the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) and its leadership can mend their ways for a better Malawi.

However, having gone this far, my observation is that Malawians are a difficult lot. Malawians are a people not ready to take criticism as an avenue to offer them an alternative view that could help them mend their ways or shape their destiny. All what Malawians would like to always hear are songs of praise even when things are not alright. We are a people, who are not even ashamed to heap ourselves with praises even when it is clear that all what we have to show is rot and more rot; that is from our government leadership going down to our opposition leaders, corporate leaders, civil society activists, business community down to an ordinary man in the street.

This is why although I would be the last one to applaud USA President Donald Trump’s ‘shithole’ remarks, I am tempted to agree with him because what is seen in Malawi is a true reflection of most of the African countries (I am using ‘most’ because I know that there are a few countries in Africa who along their leadership are doing a great job and trying their best in a bid to move forward and certainly Trump’s ‘shithole’ remarks would be out of place in these African countries but not Malawi and many more others).

Some have seen Trump’s words as mere hollers from a mad President who is known for his pathological racism that at any given opportunity he is ready for a verbal assault on African countries, the continent’s leaders and other also not so fortunate countries around the world like Haiti, Mexico etc. However, wearing sober lenses I see some sense in this madness.

Yes, the comments rightfully attracted global condemnation and fury starting from the United Nations, the African Union and several African countries with some countries on the continent going as far as summoning US ambassadors to issue official diplomatic protests. As has been the case with our modern technology, social media ‘commentators’ and ‘citizens’ alike were not left out in the frenzy with some agreeing with Trump, others disagreeing with him while the most daring went as far as applauding, defending and clapping hands in support of the USA President.

In the USA, the reaction to President Trump’s remarks was also varied and mainly dependent on which political divide one belongs to.

Hate or like him, one thing about Trump is his forthrightness. He is a man who is true to the cliché- calling a spade a spade and not a big folk. He is a man who thrives on being honest and true to himself.

Just imagine during a March 2006 appearance on “The View” with his daughter Ivanka, Trump when asked how he would react if Playboy magazine were to ever feature Ivanka’s picture on its cover. Mr. Trump responded: “I don’t think Ivanka would do that inside the magazine, although she does have a very nice figure. I’ve said that if Ivanka weren’t my daughter, perhaps I would be dating her.” This is a man who is so direct in his words on issues-private or public. All what he wanted the world to know is that he really believes that his daughter is so beautiful and has a fine figure that every man, even himself, would not resist. This was a shocker even to Joy Behar, one of the show’s co-hosts, who exclaimed, “Stop it! Oh, that’s so weird. Stop it!” But that is what Trump is and this time around he just wanted to be as truthful as possible about Africa and other equally backward countries.

Equally, all of us might have been shocked with such brutal frankness; but are we surprised? No. Some of us are not surprised, on two fronts. First, that is what Trump is all about and secondly, I think, especially us in Africa we have nothing to show that we do not deserve such derogatory definition of our being.

Yes, we might dismiss it as racist and bigotry, and be angry as much as we can that the USA President has gone overboard but let us as a continent not attempt to hit back with another verbal tirade. He has indeed thrown it to us brutally but the only way out of this; let us with our actions and a rethink of our destiny, throw it back to him, brutally and ruthlessly as well so that one day he would be forced to swallow his words in shame.

Unfortunately, if as a continent we continue having leaders who thrive on lies, self praises, corruption and theft of public resources we will forever be labelled ‘shithole’ countries. And to get rid of this accolade is a task for every proud African who is really angry about this ‘shithole’ remarks. I take it that Trump’s words came out of his own pain and anger over African countries and other states that are struggling and wallowing in poverty despite abundant resources. It is apparent in his words that Trump seems to feel the pain on our behalf because he knows our potential. Unfortunately, as Africans we are a pathetic people which seem not to feel the pain when things are going bad.

We are a continent that will sit and watch while politicians are busy ruthlessly plundering and making a big kill out of the continent’s resources and applaud and clap hands for them when they go out to western or eastern countries to beg for aid. And surely, we will continue being the ridicule of the Trumps of this world if we continue having leaders whose only preoccupation is cooking figures to portray that economically we are growing and on the right path instead of showing the real results of such blossoming economy.

We will continue being the laughing stock of Trump and his buddies, if we go on having leaders who only ‘talk’ of inflation being at its lowest point; interest rates going down; our foreign currency reserves being healthy; and that we are highly rated destination for investors because we have restored economic confidence, while evidence is there in the people who are suffering both in our cities and towns and real figures show no increase in tourists but a decline.

Honestly, I don’t understand why we are surprised and angry on this Trump ‘Shithole’ assault. Instead of being surprised and angry, let us clean our act. All our anger and frustrations should be directed at making our countries better and turn then from ‘shitholes’ to something adorable. Hitting back at this ‘honestly’ mad Trump, will just divert us from the real problems that for a long time (before Trump said it) have made our countries the ‘shitholes’ of this world.

Follow and Subscribe Nyasa TV :

Please share this Article if you like Email This Post Email This Post

More From the World

newest oldest most voted
Notify of

I am convinced that many are angry with what Trump said, but if we may take a closer look at what was said and bringing it to a huge comparison to our MALAWI, one may easily node his head in approval that its true unless otherwise. That kind of anger is what can drive us forward to change our mindset and opt for a better MALAWI to prove Trump wrong, otherwise if we continue doing what we are doing now, his words will be true mpaka kale kale


The writer is a dickhead. Only dickheads can agree with what Trump has said.

Trump just told us the truth. I wonder why Malawians ,some exemplified by comments down below behave like ostriches and burry their heads in the sand. Africa is not only a shithole but a SUPER SHITHOLE given the amount of resources we have. This is because we have very corrupt leaders, leaders that are unwilling to serve their countries. If our countries were not as described, would be have people drowning in the Mediterranean on their way to Europe? Why don’t our leaders do some introspection and make lives better for their people so that they are not described in… Read more »

Men like Hudson Mphande should understand that people like Trump who paint everything with one brush will never see the nuggets out a heap. Don’t tell me that Africa is just like a small village where everyone speaks the same language. I don’t know how many African countries Mphande has ever lived to come up with the conclusions made above. Africa is quite diverse, Amwene!!!! Narrow minded and shallow in perspective like Trump himself!!!!! Hmmm!!!!


watched the UN vote; funny how so many African countries abstained or aligned themselves to the USA for fear of aid sanctions only to be called ‘shitholes’. Beggars belief!

How many times has this cowboy goofed just a few months on the seat? No wonder some quarters have dubbed him mad. Reagan was better than him. His decisions has been always dictatorial. This is why the whole UN can prove him wrong on everything he thinks. It is during his time that North Korea has rudely exposed itself just to show this mad man that he is going too far with his decisions. Just look at his blunders on the issue of Jerusalem and Iran. Hudson should not cheat us that his reporting on Malawi politics is neutral. We… Read more »
Mika Kumbire

I have never taken Trump seriously at any point in time. Why should I take him seriously now. This is a huge time waster. It shows that we have lost direction and focus in everything. We are slowly running out of topics. Americans are beating themselves for allowing a blackman from a shithole country Kenya to rule them and do better for 10 years.


no relevance… USA was never run by a kenyan!


II am sure if Trump had called you Hudson Mphande nkho** etc. you could not have supported what he has called you and your mother, father and all your relatives that you are anthu akumayiko a kutha**


Good writing, personally I do not see any wrong doing from Trump, traditionally when someone wishes you bad things, for instance you want to construct a house and ppo are saying that you can’t do it, what do you do ? You prove to them that you are not a failure by constructing a big house beyond their thinking capacity. Trump is right.

john telford


strange but when trump requested the tapes be replayed of his speech at no time did he mention or use the word shitholes , as he said false news is everywhere


Which world do you live in John Telford? The White House is known for editing recordings.

Baba Maduapera

I totally agree with you, Nsena…The truth always pains!!!!

More From Nyasatimes